What happened
Isla de las Muñecas is a chinampa – an artificial farming islet – on the Teshuilo lagoon among the canals of Xochimilco in southern Mexico City. From the mid-20th century it was home to a recluse, Don Julián Santana Barrera. According to legend, he found the body of a drowned girl in the canal (or failed to save her), and the next day fished a doll out of the water. Believing it had belonged to the child, he hung it on a tree to honour her memory and ward off evil spirits. But the girl's ghost supposedly gave him no peace, so for decades Barrera collected dolls from rubbish heaps and traded vegetables for them, hanging hundreds more on trees and the walls of his huts. Sun and rain turned them into a ghastly collection: faded faces, empty eye sockets, stumps of arms, cobwebs in their hair. In 2001 the eighty-year-old Barrera drowned in the canal – according to the story, at the very spot where the girl died. Today the island welcomes tourists arriving by colourful trajinera boats, though some boatmen refuse to go. Visitors say the dolls turn their heads, open their eyes and whisper.
Witnesses
Barrera's family, Xochimilco boatmen and tourists; the island has featured on TV programmes such as “Expedition X.”
Explanations and hypotheses
No evidence has ever been found that the drowned girl existed – the story is known only from Barrera and his family. An elderly hermit drowning requires no supernatural explanation. The dolls' “movements” are easily explained by wind, and their condition heightens the sense of dread. The island is now a private tourist attraction run by Barrera's relatives, and visitors leave new dolls as offerings.
Legend A story handed down through generations – it can be neither confirmed nor disproved.
Sources
- Guinness World Records – The haunting story of the man who built the Island of Dolls (2022)
- Paula Froelich, Real story behind 'haunted' Island of the Dolls in Mexico (New York Post, 2021)
More: Wikipedia (pl) Wikipedia (en)